← 返回 Skills 市场
144
总下载
1
收藏
1
当前安装
2
版本数
在 OpenClaw 中安装
/install pm-chief-naysayer
功能描述
Use when a user proposes a product idea, feature concept, or product plan that needs logical stress-testing. Trigger phrases: challenge this idea, stress tes...
安全使用建议
This is an instruction-only 'devil's advocate' skill that asks pointed questions and refuses to offer solutions by design. Technically it is low-risk—no installs, no credentials, no files—but be aware of behavioural/UX risks: it will be confrontational (no praise, forced challenge, limited to 1–2 questions) and can frustrate or derail conversations if used inappropriately. Try it in a controlled setting first, review sample outputs to ensure tone and safety fit your context, and avoid enabling it as always:true or giving it automatic broad invocation if you want to limit unexpected adversarial interactions.
功能分析
Type: OpenClaw Skill
Name: pm-chief-naysayer
Version: 1.0.1
The skill bundle contains instructions for an AI agent to act as a 'Chief Naysayer' for product logic stress-testing. The content is limited to markdown instructions (SKILL.md) and metadata (_meta.json), with no executable code, scripts, or network requests. The instructions define a strict persona and a three-stage questioning framework focused entirely on product management critique, lacking any indicators of malicious intent, data exfiltration, or harmful prompt injection.
能力评估
Purpose & Capability
Name/description match the SKILL.md: the skill's sole function is to ask hard, scoped questions. No unexpected binaries, env vars, or config paths are requested.
Instruction Scope
The SKILL.md is prescriptive and enforces adversarial conversational behavior (zero praise, 1–2 questions, stage gating, drift detection). This is consistent with the stated purpose, but it is very constraining and may produce a brusque or repetitive user experience; it does not instruct the agent to read files, access env vars, or exfiltrate data.
Install Mechanism
No install spec or code files; instruction-only skills have minimal disk or network risk.
Credentials
No environment variables, credentials, or config paths are requested—proportional and minimal.
Persistence & Privilege
always:false and normal user-invocable/autonomous settings. The skill does not request permanent presence or modify other skills/configs.
如何使用
- 确保已安装 OpenClaw（本地或 Docker 部署）
- 在对话框中输入安装命令：
/install pm-chief-naysayer - 安装完成后，直接呼叫该 Skill 的名称或使用
/pm-chief-naysayer触发 - 根据 Skill 的参数说明提供必要输入，即可获得结构化输出
版本历史
v1.0.1
[fix] Self-correction rule round number error
v1.0.0
pm-chief-naysayer 1.0.0
- Initial release of the "Product Manager's Chief Naysayer" skill for logical stress-testing of product ideas.
- Enforces strict rules: zero praise, questions only (no advice/answers), and max 1–2 killer questions per round.
- Proceeds sequentially through three stages: Foundation (motivation, contradiction), Truth (evidence credibility), and Execution (practical risks).
- Requires concrete evidence for claims and aggressively detects proposition drift and defensive/complex argumentation.
- Applies hard constraints on question format, framing, and advancement—ensuring only well-founded ideas progress.
元数据
常见问题
Product Manager's Chief Naysayer 是什么？
Use when a user proposes a product idea, feature concept, or product plan that needs logical stress-testing. Trigger phrases: challenge this idea, stress tes... 它是一个面向 Claude Code / OpenClaw 的 AI Agent Skill 插件，目前累计下载 144 次。
如何安装 Product Manager's Chief Naysayer？
在 OpenClaw 或 Claude Code 对话框中运行命令「/install pm-chief-naysayer」即可一键安装，无需额外配置。
Product Manager's Chief Naysayer 是免费的吗？
是的，Product Manager's Chief Naysayer 完全免费，采用 MIT-0 许可证，可自由下载、安装和使用。
Product Manager's Chief Naysayer 支持哪些平台？
Product Manager's Chief Naysayer 跨平台运行，可在任意部署了 OpenClaw / Claude Code 的环境中使用（cross-platform）。
谁开发了 Product Manager's Chief Naysayer？
由 Trient（@trient）开发并维护，当前版本 v1.0.1。
推荐 Skills