← 返回 Skills 市场
long1973m

objection

作者 马龙 · GitHub ↗ · v1.0.0 · MIT-0
cross-platform ⚠ suspicious
94
总下载
0
收藏
0
当前安装
1
版本数
在 OpenClaw 中安装
/install objection
功能描述
Activate this skill whenever the user asks you to "find problems," "poke holes," "stress test," "play devil's advocate," "be critical," "challenge this," "fi...
安全使用建议
This is an instruction-only 'dissent' skill whose goal is legitimate (find problems) and which has no install or credential requests — but its runtime mandates are absolutist and underspecified. Before installing or enabling it broadly, consider: 1) Fix the naming mismatch (objection vs dissent) and ask the author to clarify allowed verification actions. 2) Require explicit boundaries in SKILL.md: what the agent is permitted to run, what paths/services are off-limits, and whether it may request credentials. 3) If you let it run, use it in a controlled context (non-production data/sandboxed execution) so any suggested 'run' or 'test' steps cannot accidentally leak secrets or modify systems. 4) Be prepared for the agent to ask for additional permissions (access to repos, test accounts, or API keys) to perform the verifications it demands — only grant those on a case-by-case, minimal-needed basis. If you need stricter guarantees, ask the skill author to add explicit verification procedures and allowed tools rather than leaving them to agent discretion.
功能分析
Type: OpenClaw Skill Name: objection Version: 1.0.0 The 'dissent' skill bundle (slug: objection) is a set of behavioral instructions designed to make the AI agent act as a critical reviewer or 'devil's advocate.' It provides a structured framework for identifying flaws, edge cases, and logical gaps in user-provided artifacts. While it uses strong language to override default helpfulness biases and ignore time constraints, these instructions are aligned with the stated purpose of adversarial review and do not contain any indicators of data exfiltration, malicious execution, or unauthorized access.
能力评估
Purpose & Capability
Name/description (registry: 'objection') and the SKILL.md's internal name ('dissent') differ, but both describe the same adversarial-review intent. The required capabilities declared (none) are plausible for a purely rhetorical adversarial-review skill. Minor incoherence: package name vs internal name — likely benign but should be fixed for clarity.
Instruction Scope
The SKILL.md mandates exhaustive verification (e.g., "Run it. Test it. Trace the logic step by step.") and forbids hedging. However it gives no bounds or mechanism for execution, and does not explicitly constrain what resources the agent may access to perform those verifications. That ambiguity could cause the agent to attempt actions beyond the user's intent (running code, contacting external services, reading files) or to request credentials without explicit justification.
Install Mechanism
Instruction-only skill with no install spec and no code files — lowest installation risk. Nothing is written to disk by the skill bundle itself.
Credentials
The skill declares no environment variables or credentials (proportional). However, the instructions demand active verification that in practice may require credentials, binaries, or filesystem access (e.g., to run tests against real systems). The lack of declared required resources leaves a gap: the skill may prompt the agent to request extra access at runtime.
Persistence & Privilege
always is false and the skill is user-invocable only. It does not request persistent system presence or modify other skills. No privilege escalation indicators in metadata.
如何使用
  1. 确保已安装 OpenClaw(本地或 Docker 部署)
  2. 在对话框中输入安装命令:/install objection
  3. 安装完成后,直接呼叫该 Skill 的名称或使用 /objection 触发
  4. 根据 Skill 的参数说明提供必要输入,即可获得结构化输出
版本历史
v1.0.0
Initial release of the "dissent" skill, focusing on adversarial, problem-seeking review. - Activates when the user explicitly requests critical analysis (e.g., "play devil's advocate", "find flaws", "challenge this", or "/dissent"). - Prioritizes surfacing all possible flaws, risks, assumptions, gaps, and failure modes in any artifact (code, arguments, plans, etc.), without balancing for politeness or affirmation. - Outlines strict non-negotiable rules: never assume something is correct without verifying, never outsource responsibility, and never skip thoroughness to save time. - Provides a multi-layered approach for identifying logical, empirical, edge case, risk, assumption, verification gap, and adversarial issues. - Specifies a structured output for findings and unverified claims. - Establishes a mindset centered on maximum problem discovery and thorough critical review.
元数据
Slug objection
版本 1.0.0
许可证 MIT-0
累计安装 0
当前安装数 0
历史版本数 1
常见问题

objection 是什么?

Activate this skill whenever the user asks you to "find problems," "poke holes," "stress test," "play devil's advocate," "be critical," "challenge this," "fi... 它是一个面向 Claude Code / OpenClaw 的 AI Agent Skill 插件,目前累计下载 94 次。

如何安装 objection?

在 OpenClaw 或 Claude Code 对话框中运行命令「/install objection」即可一键安装,无需额外配置。

objection 是免费的吗?

是的,objection 完全免费,采用 MIT-0 许可证,可自由下载、安装和使用。

objection 支持哪些平台?

objection 跨平台运行,可在任意部署了 OpenClaw / Claude Code 的环境中使用(cross-platform)。

谁开发了 objection?

由 马龙(@long1973m)开发并维护,当前版本 v1.0.0。

💬 留言讨论