Peer Review Response Drafter

Assist in drafting professional peer review response letters. Trigger when user mentions "reviewer comments", "response letter", "peer review", "revise and r...

This skill appears coherent and limited to drafting responses. Before installing or using it, consider: 1) privacy—you will likely paste or upload unpublished manuscript text and reviewer comments, so avoid supplying sensitive or embargoed data to third parties or shared environments; 2) execution context—the included Python script runs locally in the agent environment, so review the script if you run it outside a sandbox; 3) trust—if you intend to run this in a managed/cloud agent, confirm the operator's data handling policy. If you want extra assurance, inspect the full scripts/main.py file (no network calls or credential access were found in the provided content).

Type: OpenClaw Skill Name: peer-review-response-drafter Version: 1.0.0 The skill's core purpose is benign, but the `scripts/main.py` file contains a significant vulnerability. It allows arbitrary file read and write operations via the `--input` and `--output` command-line arguments (and interactive mode's save functionality) without any path sanitization or restriction. This directly contradicts the security claims in `SKILL.md` that state 'Input file paths validated (no ../ traversal)' and 'Output directory restricted to workspace'. An attacker controlling the script's arguments could exploit this to read or overwrite arbitrary files on the system, depending on the agent's permissions. There is no evidence of intentional malicious behavior, but this is a critical vulnerability.