← Back to Skills Marketplace
Roundtable Adaptive
by
JimmyClanker
· GitHub ↗
· v2.9.1
763
Downloads
0
Stars
1
Active Installs
14
Versions
Install in OpenClaw
/install roundtable-adaptive
Description
Adaptive multi-model AI roundtable. Runs up to 4 AI models (configurable) in 2 debate rounds with cross-critique and formal consensus scoring. Requires a con...
Usage Guidance
This skill appears to do what it says, but check these before installing: 1) The skill requires an Anthropic API key for the Claude panel — only provide it if you trust the skill and understand provider billing. 2) Full multi-model operation is optional: OpenAI and Blockrun integrations are supported but require extra credentials/config (OPENAI_API_KEY, BLOCKRUN_PROXY_URL) and, for Blockrun, installing a plugin and funding a wallet — expect small per-run costs if you enable them. 3) The skill will post to Discord channels/threads and needs permission to list/create threads and post messages; set the output channel intentionally (ROUNDTABLE_OUTPUT_CHANNEL/panels.json). 4) Results and logs are written to your workspace memory directory ({workspace}/memory/roundtables or ~/clawd/memory/roundtables) — if you need to prevent local persistence, do not enable the skill or modify the paths. 5) The package source/homepage is missing and the registry lists an owner ID but no homepage — if provenance matters, ask the publisher for a source repo or audit the files. 6) If you won't use Blockrun/OpenAI features, you can run in Claude-only degraded mode; otherwise, verify you trust any third-party proxies (Blockrun) before pointing local services at them. If you want greater assurance, request the source repo or a signed release and check the exact message/action APIs the agent will call in your environment.
Capability Analysis
Type: OpenClaw Skill
Name: roundtable-adaptive
Version: 2.9.1
The skill is classified as suspicious due to critical prompt injection vulnerabilities. The user's input `[PROMPT]` is directly inserted into multiple AI prompt templates (`prompts/meta-panel.md`, `prompts/round1.md`, `prompts/round2-cross-critique.md`, `prompts/round3-validation.md`) without apparent sanitization. This allows a malicious user to inject arbitrary instructions into the AI models, potentially leading to unauthorized actions, data exfiltration (e.g., API keys via `env()` or `message()` actions), or remote code execution if the agent has access to shell commands. Additionally, the `[CURRENT_CONTEXT]` derived from `web_search(query = prompt)` also presents a potential vector for injecting malicious instructions via manipulated search results.
Capability Assessment
Purpose & Capability
The declared requirement (ANTHROPIC_API_KEY and providers.anthropic) fits the primary purpose (Claude-based roundtables). The skill is instruction-only and orchestrates multiple models (optional OpenAI/Blockrun slots) which matches the description and panel configs. The disk writes (workspace memory/roundtables) and Discord messaging are expected for an orchestration/orchestration+UI skill.
Instruction Scope
SKILL.md instructs the agent to perform web searches, list/create Discord threads (message actions), spawn persistent session agents, run cross-critique rounds, and save outputs to local workspace memory. Those actions are within the skill's stated purpose, but they do involve network calls (web search, model providers) and writing structured files to disk. Also: it refers to an output channel variable (ROUNDTABLE_OUTPUT_CHANNEL) and automatic channel auto-trigger behavior — users should confirm these posting behaviors and needed messaging permissions.
Install Mechanism
There is no install spec; the skill is instruction-only (lowest install risk). It does recommend optionally installing a Blockrun OpenClaw plugin and running a local Blockrun gateway (and funding a wallet) for additional providers; that advice is external to the skill and not automatically executed by it.
Credentials
The registry only requires ANTHROPIC_API_KEY and providers.anthropic config, which is proportionate. However the SKILL.md and panels.json reference optional items not declared as required env vars/config in the registry: OPENAI_API_KEY, BLOCKRUN_PROXY_URL (default http://localhost:8402), and a ROUNDTABLE_OUTPUT_CHANNEL config. Those are optional but referenced frequently; users should be aware additional credentials/configs will be needed for the full experience and that Blockrun usage may require local proxy access and on-chain wallet funding.
Persistence & Privilege
always:false (normal). The skill's runtime spawns persistent panel sessions in Discord threads (expected for multi-round interaction), but it does not request always-enabled privilege or claim to modify other skills' configs. It writes its own results/state to a workspace memory directory (normal for this type of skill).
How to Use
- Make sure OpenClaw is installed (local or Docker)
- Run the install command in chat:
/install roundtable-adaptive - After installation, invoke the skill by name or use
/roundtable-adaptive - Provide required inputs per the skill's parameter spec and get structured output
Version History
v2.9.1
Trust/consistency patch: aligned runtime requirements with optional providers, clarified persistent-vs-one-shot agent behavior, reduced scanner ambiguity
v2.8.1
Quick patch: Priority A dedup and quick-mode hardening
v2.9.0
Priority A: root-channel auto-trigger, dedup thread reuse, quick-mode validation, scorecard logging updates
v2.8.0
Fixed requiredEnv format (string array, not objects — was rendering as [object Object]). Replaced hardcoded ~/clawd/memory paths with {workspace}/memory placeholder.
v2.7.0
Fixed registry visibility gap: switched metadata key from openclaw to clawdis, added explicit requires.env (ANTHROPIC_API_KEY required, OPENAI_API_KEY and BLOCKRUN_PROXY_URL optional) and requires.config (providers.anthropic, providers.openai-codex, providers.blockrun). Added config.requiredEnv entries with required/optional flags and full descriptions. Changed all session spawns to mode=run (one-shot, no persistent agents). Registry now surfaces correct credential requirements.
v2.6.0
Complete rewrite of operational instructions. Removed all hardcoded IDs, service URLs, and platform-specific assumptions. Skill now describes behavior declaratively; all runtime choices (model, channel, output path) are configurable by the user. Blockrun optional.
v2.5.0
Addressed reviewer flags: removed hardcoded Discord channel ID (now configurable), removed mandatory blockrun/sonnet orchestrator (uses your default model), all panel agents declared as one-shot mode=run (no persistent background activity), Blockrun fully optional, setup docs expanded.
v2.4.0
Fixed mismatches: GPT-5.2 → GPT-5.3 Codex throughout. Removed curl|bash install guidance — replaced with safe openclaw plugins install command. All model references now consistent with panels.json.
v2.3.0
Explicit requirement declarations: Blockrun proxy, filesystem write scope, provider dependencies. Added full Setup section. Degraded mode documented.
v2.2.0
v2.2: thread-bound architecture — each roundtable spawns 4 persistent agents in a dedicated thread (mode=session, thread=true); Round 2 via sessions_send reusing existing sessions; synthesis also thread-bound for follow-up Q&A
v2.1.3
v2.1: adaptive meta-panel workflow design, web-search grounding, self-authored digests, consensus scoring, Round 3 validation, neutral synthesis, blockrun premium panel, fail-continue, budget profile, full English, parametric config
v2.1.2
test visibility
v2.1.1
v2.1.1: all Italian text translated to English, removed agent-specific references, parametric channel config
v2.1.0
v2.1: meta-panel workflow design (4 premium models), web-search grounding, self-authored digests, consensus scoring 1-5, Round 3 validation, neutral synthesis model, blockrun premium panel, fail-continue, budget profile, score parsing resilience, placeholder contract, full README + examples
Metadata
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Roundtable Adaptive?
Adaptive multi-model AI roundtable. Runs up to 4 AI models (configurable) in 2 debate rounds with cross-critique and formal consensus scoring. Requires a con... It is an AI Agent Skill for Claude Code / OpenClaw, with 763 downloads so far.
How do I install Roundtable Adaptive?
Run "/install roundtable-adaptive" in the OpenClaw or Claude Code chat to install it in one step — no extra setup required.
Is Roundtable Adaptive free?
Yes, Roundtable Adaptive is completely free (open-source). You can download, install and use it at no cost.
Which platforms does Roundtable Adaptive support?
Roundtable Adaptive is cross-platform and runs anywhere OpenClaw / Claude Code is available (cross-platform).
Who created Roundtable Adaptive?
It is built and maintained by JimmyClanker (@jimmyclanker); the current version is v2.9.1.
More Skills