Citation Diversifier (budget-as-constraints) [NO NEW FACTS]

Purpose: fix a common survey failure mode:

• the draft reads under-cited (or reuses the same few citations everywhere)
• the pipeline fails the global unique-citation gate

This skill does not change prose by itself. It produces a constraint sheet: output/CITATION_BUDGET_REPORT.md.

Inputs

• output/DRAFT.md
• outline/outline.yml (H3 ids/titles; used to allocate budgets per subsection)
• outline/writer_context_packs.jsonl (source of allowed_bibkeys_{selected,mapped,chapter,global} per H3)
• citations/ref.bib

Output

• output/CITATION_BUDGET_REPORT.md

Non-negotiables (NO NEW FACTS)

• Only propose citation keys that exist in citations/ref.bib.
• Only propose keys that are in-scope for the target H3 (prefer subsection-first scope; use chapter/global only when truly cross-cutting).
• Do not propose “padding citations” that would require adding new claims or new numbers.

What a good budget report looks like (contract)

The report should feel like a constraint sheet, not a random list:

• It states the blocking policy target and the gap-to-target (how many unique keys are missing; policy default is recommended).
• For each H3, it proposes a scope-safe budget sized to actually close the gap:
  • small gaps: 3-6 keys / H3 is often enough
  • A150++ gaps: plan for ~6-12 keys / H3 (and avoid duplicates across H3 budgets)
• It gives placement guidance (where in the subsection those keys can be embedded without adding new facts).

Canonical (parseable) lines required (downstream validators depend on these):

• The target is derived from queries.md:citation_target (recommended by default for A150++).
• - Global target (policy; blocking): >= \x3CN> ...
• - Gap: \x3CK> (gap-to-target; if 0, injection can be a no-op PASS)

Optional (always reported; may be blocking depending on citation_target):

• - Global recommended target: >= \x3CN> ...
• - Gap to recommended: \x3CK>

Recommended prioritization (scope-safe):

• allowed_bibkeys_selected → allowed_bibkeys_mapped → allowed_bibkeys_chapter
• Use allowed_bibkeys_global only for:
  • benchmarks/protocol papers
  • widely-used datasets/suites
  • cross-cutting surveys/method papers referenced across chapters

How this connects to writing (LLM-first)

After you generate the budget report:

• Apply it using citation-injector (LLM edits to output/DRAFT.md, NO NEW FACTS).
• Then run draft-polisher to remove any “budget dump voice” while keeping citation keys unchanged.

Important: citation-injector is LLM-first. Its script is validation-only.

Workflow

1. Diagnose the global situation

• Read output/DRAFT.md and estimate the “unique-key gap” (or use pipeline-auditor’s FAIL reason).

2. Allocate budgets per H3 (scope-first)

• Use outline/outline.yml to enumerate H3s in paper order.
• For each H3, read its allowed key sets from outline/writer_context_packs.jsonl.
• Pick a small set of unused keys that strengthen positioning without requiring new claims.

3. Write output/CITATION_BUDGET_REPORT.md Required structure:

• - Status: PASS|FAIL
• - Global target (policy; blocking): >= \x3CN> ...
• - Gap: \x3CK>
• ## Summary (gap + strategy)
• ## Per-subsection budgets (H3 id/title → suggested keys → placement hint)

Script (optional; deterministic report generator)

If you want a deterministic first-pass budget report, run the helper script. Treat it as a baseline and refine the plan as needed.

Quick Start

• python scripts/run.py --help
• python scripts/run.py --workspace workspaces/\x3Cws>

All Options

• --workspace \x3Cdir>
• --unit-id \x3CU###> (optional)
• --inputs \x3Csemicolon-separated> (rare override; prefer defaults)
• --outputs \x3Csemicolon-separated> (rare override; default writes output/CITATION_BUDGET_REPORT.md)
• --checkpoint \x3CC#> (optional)

Examples

• Default IO:
  • python scripts/run.py --workspace workspaces/\x3Cws>

Done criteria

• output/CITATION_BUDGET_REPORT.md exists and has actionable, in-scope budgets.
• After applying the plan via citation-injector, pipeline-auditor no longer FAILs on global unique citations.